Skip to product information

Haymaker™ Adjustable Reactive Foam Pillows with Twisticuffs (2-Pack)

Non-Member Price

$189 $139

Member Price


Members save an extra $30 | Learn More

Our proprietary pillow design is unique in the bedding industry.  Filled with Twisticuffs – our specialized blend of memory and reactive, noodle-shaped foams – no matter what you want in a pillow, the Haymaker delivers.  Easily adjust the pillow to match your perfect sleep style. The Haymaker™ sleeps cool throughout the night, providing the perfect blend of comfort and support.  Once adjusted, simply allow the noodle foam to conform to your head, delivering significantly more responsiveness, airflow, and comfort than traditional shredded or molded/block foam pillows.  


Dimensions, Materials & Care


Standard: 18" x 24"
King: 18" x 32"


500 gram plush Tencel Knit Pillow Casing. Memory and Latex-like foam
blend fill the inside of the pillow and are crafted from sustainable, renewable soybean feedstock.


Machine wash cover only in cool water with mild detergent. Tumble dry on low.

Shipping, Warranty, Returns


Ships same or next business day (unless otherwise noted)


We offer a 1-year limited warranty that covers manufacturing and workmanship defects. If you do notice anything out of the ordinary, simply reach out to us via the chat feature located in the bottom right corner of our website.


All of our products come with a 100-Night Sleep Trial, and a hassle-free return process. If our products are not meeting your expectations, chat with us online and a representative will walk you through the steps.

100-Night Sleep Trial™

All of our products come with a 100-Night Sleep Trial, and a hassle-free return process. If for any reason you are unsatisfied with your purchase – within 100 days of our order – our products may be returned for a full refund.

Pillow-Fight Club™

Pillow-Fight Club™ is our
membership club — providing you with new pillows every 12 months, as is recommended by health & sleep professionals

- Save significantly by
purchasing your GoodPillow™ via our Pillow-Fight Club™

Adjustable Comfort

Say goodbye to one-sized fits all pillows! People are shaped differently and sleep differently, so we made the Haymaker™ adjustable to solve for figurative and literal pain points. Just add or remove fill from the pillow to create the loft that suits your needs. Keep in mind that it can take up to two weeks to acclimate to your new pillow.

Marshmallowy feel

Introducing Twisticuffs™ – a brand new blend of noodle-shaped foam for the extreme sleeper. The blend of latex-like and memory foam noodles compress and rebound quickly providing an ultra-comfy, squishy feel unrivaled by medium-firm pillows. Movement triggers airflow so you'll sleep on the cool side of the pillow all night long.

Trust the Experts

We’re proud to have achieved CertiPUR-US® and OEKO-TEX® STANDARD 100 certifications, meaning that our pillow has been rigorously tested for harmful chemicals by both organizations and has met the top product safety standards.

Are Twisticuffs more comfortable than block or shredded memory foam pillows?
Absolutely! Block and shredded foams aren't horrible, but they tend to lock into place, get hot, and wear down faster. Twisticuffs have a long noodle like cut that ensures the pillow moves with your head. This keeps the pillow cool, and helps to retain its shape longer.
How does the Twisticuff foam compare to shredded memory foam pillows?
Both contain memory foam, but that's where the similarities end. Shredded memory foam consists of foam shards gathered up from the production floor, put into a shredder and used to make pillows. Our foams are punched from the same foam so that every Haymaker has the same feel as the previous pillow. We also don't have plastics and glue mixed in to the fill as commonly found in shredded memory foam pillows. If you have a shredded memory foam pillow, just cut it open and see for yourself, there really is no comparison.
Can I wash the Haymaker pillow?
You can wash the Tencel cover. Just remove the Twisticuffs and wash the cover in cold water with mild detergent and tumble dry on low heat. If desired, pillow cover can be professionally dry cleaned. Do not wash or dry memory foam. Wash the pillowcase only and as needed.
Why should I join Pillow-Fight Club?
Join Pillow-Fight Club and you'll recieve 2 FRESH, new pillows every year AND you'll save an average of 21% on all our other bedding products!

Customer Reviews

Based on 79 reviews
David S. (Mission, KS)
They made it right

Logistics delays make it difficult for everyone lately but this company took it upon themselves to reach out and make it right. Excellent pillows, excellent company.

R W. (Minneapolis, MN)
Best Pillow Ever

I was a little apprehensive buying these pillows based on the experience of using other foam filled pillows. Those pillows just felt weird. I could feel the various pieces no matter how I tried to fluff them up and it wasn't possible to create a consistent surface. These pillows are on a whole other level. The technology behind these allows for a consistent surface and feel better than any feather filled pillow I have used. The fact that I could customize the pillows was what intrigued me and just as advertised, I was able to create the perfect pillows for the best support I have ever had. I don't think I will ever consider buying any other type in the future.

Joan C. (Houston, TX)
I LOVE this pillow!

It's hard to believe a pillow can make such a difference, but this pillow does! I am a side sleeper and this Haymaker pillow is perfect for me!

Scott H. (Gig Harbor, WA)
So much better than our previous pillows!

Our previous pillows had turned into mush and kept falling through the cracks in the bed. Our Haymakers have the perfect amount of firmness!

Mary B. (Tucson, AZ)
Excellent Pillow

Love the Haymaker- Easy to adjust fill for a perfect fit. Sleeping great! Will be recommending to family and friends.